A Divine Copp Out

I promise to avoid bad puns in future titles. David Copp advances a “society-centered” theory (SCT) of the justification of moral standards in Morality, Normativity, and Society.  It’s a standard-based theory.  “Standard” is used in this context to name a rule or imperative, for example, […] Read More

Paul Edwards 1923-2004

As some of you may already know, Paul Edwards passed away on December 9th. The New York Times Obituary can be found here (login required; thanks to Brian Leiter for the link). Edwards was known mostly for being the editor of The Encyclopedia of Philosophy. […] Read More

Dreier and Negating an Attitude

In Madison, Jamie, echoing Nicholas Unwin, posed a problem for expressivists generally, and for Gibbard specifically.  As I understand it, the problem is that expressivists have no apparent semantic account of a certain kind of negation represented in (N2), which is to be distinguished from […] Read More

Not-so-divine command theory

I’m slated to teach moral theory next quarter, and I’m confronting a problem that’s plagued me in the past: whether (and how) to teach the divine command theory (DCT) of ethics.  I’ve taught it in past courses, and have never felt entirely satisfied with how […] Read More

A little levity

It’s clear from recent posts and comments that we’ve all been thinking much too hard.  So in the spirit of holiday good cheer, I hereby present my own effort at the Ultimate Hard Case in Ethics (UHCE).  Suggestions for making it still harder are of […] Read More

Subjectivism and Moral Criticism

Suppose that Sue’s considered opinion was that Joe had all things considered most reason to do one thing. In what sense could Sue, in consistency with that thought, earnestly criticize Joe for failing to do something else? Of course, it could be that Sue thinks […] Read More